CGY - NSH (2-3 rejected)

Flames send:
Preds send:

Flames accept!

I accept. When I traded rinne My best player was Neal and in that trade I received giroux. And now my forwards are Lucic Ladd staal krecji burns Henrique. Receiving giroux and giving back Marc staal for the same player seems like a steal for me so why not. I can afford to pay up now for guys I want and I want rinne back.

0-1.. rinne 91 for varly 89 is fair given rinne is 32 and sure to decline..brodie 81 for staal 87 way off for me with brodie a 25 yr old 4 red.. sorry i think preds over paying on the d swap.

1-1 I think this is Brodie's jump year. I tried trading a few times for him cause of that. For me, every overall above 87 or so really separates a player because there are so few that high.

Preds gets a younger guy with potential and the best player. I think Flames wins, but it's not that off.

Considering Rinne was traded for Giroux this isnt far off. Stall is DFD great body weak speed, shoot and puck skills while Brodie is opposite. Not a big difference for top 3 goalie Rinne was considered for.

25 yr old 4 red is not a jumper though pens lmao best case 83

2-1 First of all my bro gets a ton of cap once he resigns Staal, second of all Rinne will drop  but will porbably be 87 more or less next season and stay like that for the next 3 seasons ( i'm guessing). And third of all you never know who will jump and how much . Everybody told me Skinner will stay 87 or 88 max, and look at him now. So i would cut the talk in trades when i see "he will be this ovr and retire at that age" . All in all its a fare deal because preds gets one of the best goalies in game. And i've seen really bad trades voted YES so yea

I vote no don't feel like Preds doesn't receive enough value back On this trade I imagine rinne to decline after a season and Varly is much younger. Don't see why Preds should give up a top pairing D man and get an older goalie !
Take a look at the initial trade flames made for rinne and you will see why this trade makes to sense

http://www.gmchl.net/t1730-phi-cgy-3-0-approved

Part #1Flames basically gave away an 87 younger goalie initially for rinne and downgraded one overall from hanz to orielly

Part#2 Flames receives a 89 young goalie from Preds for rinne plus a #2 D man 87 overall in stall

Like kings said its way off thanks for reading this

2-2

Rinne dropped to 89 and Brodie didn't grow so now it's
Rinne 89
Brodie 81
For
Varlamov 89
Staal 87

Since when did guys drop at 32 wtf

2-3