CGY - COL (3-0 Approved)

CGY sends:

D M. Giordano 87 overall 31 years old 4 white $4.020M 2yl
LW M. Klimchuk 70 overall 19 years old 4 yellow $0.925 3yl
C S. Monahhan 84 overall 19 years old 4.5 yellow $0.925M 2yl
LW J. Hudler 85 overall 30 years old 4 white $4.000M 2yl
LW J. Gaudreau 76 overall 21 years old 4 green $0.925 2yl

COL sends:

LW G. Landeskog 88 overall 21 years old 4.5 yellow $5.570M 7yl
C R. O`Reilly 87 overall 23 years old 4 green $6.000M 2yl
D E. Johnson 85 overall 26 years old 4.5 red $3.750M 2yl
2016 2nd round pick

Want to shake things up.

I approve the deal....

This puts my current roster in shambles for a few years being they still young... But this trade gives me depth and upgrade on D on this terrible lack of depth...

0-1
think i have authority to vote on this now sens?, but it looks pretty lopsided IMO, Calgary is giving up too much.

Well I appreciate your vote as everyone has their own breakdown / opinion / interpretations..... I suppose Milan being a long time member has merit to the deal and I will explain why we both did this deal...

First I don't get the better players for 2-3 seasons.... and when my guys progress Huds/Gio will be over 33-34....

Flames have Bennett coming up and a mass of specs where he still does great in this deal.. We are both happy and respectfully, The guys I gave up are NO JOKE..... Helps both sides...

WingsGM wrote:0-1
think i have authority to vote on this now sens?, but it looks pretty lopsided IMO, Calgary is giving up too much.

You cant vote. Need to be around more than couple of days to become a TAB.

1-0

More or less, the way I see it OReilly and Gio cancel, Johnson and Monahan cancel and that leaves Landeskog and a second for Klimchuk Hudler and Gaudreau. Gaudreau and Klimchuk are still a ways off I think so that's not too bad.

Colorado wins this, but neither team is handicapped, so in my view it's not lopsided enough to veto.

2-0

I agree with Pens breakdown of the trade and given the age of some of the players in the deal and how quickly they can regress for avs it works for me. Oreilly and Johnson for Gio and Monahan is even and lande 88 and a second even for klimchuk hudler and gadreau who needs a few seasons to grow.

3-0 book it. it gonna take a while, but avs will grow

I would have given 4 - 0 as well... benefits both teams. Plus all American votes count as 2 so would have been 5 - 0

if you just write jesus on your ballot, they count it as a republican vote.