Anaheim/San Jose

San Jose sends

Ryan Murray 86 overall 4.5 gold 22 year old 3.7 million dollars 1 year
Lindholm 85 overall 4.5 gold 21 year old 3.9 million 4 years

Ducks send

Silverberg 85 overall 2.5 million 2 years
Getz 92 overall 8 million 4 years


Thanks for the trade ducks I give up two stud young D men that I love and should be awesome for you however I gain some O and I really need that. This trade worked out nicely ducks needs the D I needs the O.

I accept. Works perfectly both ways. I like to build from the net out and this is the perfect start. Plus I hate how Getzlaf is balding so soon. Freaks me out.

Ahahhaah thats hilarious

0-1 haha really.. not sure i need to explain or see numbers on the ducks players but 92 is a top 5 forward in the game seems like ducks geting hosed.. i know lindholm and murray could grown but even silferberg a stud 85 and think this trade awful for ducks

Murray and Lindholm will become beasts  in game. This in my opinion is awful for Sharks defense. He'll get one of the top C in the game but i'm not sure how his defence will look after this, i guess its worth it . Silferberg is a good winger but i cant call him a stud. I'll give it a yes since 2 4.5 yellow prospects who will play for good 10 seasons is enough for Getz and silferberg for me

1-1

Agree with you canes take a huge hit on my D to boost O hopefully it doesn't bite me in the ass. As for the fairness of this trade like you said two 4.5 stars who are already 85 or higher and both have 90 plus potential possibilities, I believe make the value very fair.

2-1 I have seen what Gets turns into over time..... Over paid bum....its now for future..

kingz(icyrambo12) wrote:0-1 haha really.. not sure i need to explain or see numbers on the ducks players but 92 is a top 5 forward in the game seems like ducks geting hosed.. i know lindholm and murray could grown but even silferberg a stud 85 and think this trade awful for ducks

I agree, i don't know how you veto some of the other trades and allow this trade to go thru. I'm not a voter, but this is questionable trade imo.
Getz is a top 5 C in this league right now and will be for awhile still.
Silver is already worth one of those two players..
I think it is close, but i think Sharks should be adding a bit more.

85 = 85
92 > 86

Sure that 86 has "potential" to reach whatever you think he will.
But in reality RIGHT NOW 92 is 6 stats off Murray's rating, which imo is huge.
Are you willing to take the risk of that Ducks?

3-1
2 players who are already very good and can/will grow for 2 players who are in all likelihood not going to grow anymore, and 1 of them is dangerously close to regressing.

so much for first dibs on silfverberg

honestly think sharks getting raped here. Errrrrbody knows what lindholm becomes. and murray is already better than silfverberg